Every year we hear new cases of college athletes accepting money and gifts from boosters. This results in players being suspended, coaches being fired, schools being fined, athletic programs being banned from post-season play, forfeiting previous game and even losing scholarships. The past few years have been really bad for the NCAA.
The USC Trojans were forced to forfeit an entire season, had a National Championship revoked, and had 30 scholarships taken away because of Reggie Bush accepting improper benefits. Bush was forced to give his Heisman Trophy award back. USC’s basketball program has received punishment for O.J Mayo’s NCAA violations.
This year’s NFL number one draft pick Cam Newton was accused for him and his father taking money from boosters. However, Newton was not found guilty for any of the accusations.
Ohio State University football program was punished for multiple players headlined by Terrelle Pryor for taking cash and selling sports memorabilia in exchange for money and tattoos. Players were suspended and Coach Jim Tressel was fired by OSU because he knew about all of the scandals, but decided to protect his players instead of notifying the NCAA.
North Carolina’s football program had high expectations last season until they were hit with player suspensions. Seven of the players were suspended for the entire season and three of them were first round draft picks this year. Just like OSU, UNC fired their head coach Butch Davis.
The most recent allegations and possibly the worst ever in NCAA history are against the Miami Hurricanes football program. Nevin Shapiro was a familiar face around the Hurricanes for the last eight years and claimed to have given improper benefits to 72 former and current Miami athletes. The NCAA has ruled that 12 Miami players will be punished. Some have to miss games and some will have to pay back the benefits that they received.
Boosters are contacting these athletes before they even sign a letter of intent. Before the top high school athletes has a chance to decide what college they want to attend they have money, cars, clothes, jewelry etc. offered to them. These athletes usually don’t have money to afford expensive things, so when they have these people approaching them and offering them gifts it’s hard for them to turn them down. By the time that they finally go to school, they have already become accustomed to accepting gifts from boosters that once they get to college they are used to it and don’t have a problem accepting more. A few reasons why boosters give things to these athletes is because in return they expect the athletes to go where they want them to go or they expect for the athletes to pay them back and then some once they make it to the league.
Is it fair to blame the players?
Yes, you can say that the players know the rules and have the choice to make the right decision, but like many things that easier said then done. The NCAA is a multi-billion dollar industry with the best business plan. They make billions off of college athletes hard work and name, but don’t compensate them for it financially. Many will say that they get compensated with an education, but is that enough? A lot of athletes only go to school because they have to. If they had the choice a lot would go pro straight out of high school.
Being a student-athlete is a very difficult thing to do. They barely have any free time. So if they want to have a job to have money in their pocket, chances are they don’t have the time for it. So when boosters go to athletes to give them these improper benefits, they are more willing to accept them since they have no source of income.
So how can the NCAA reduce this?
Everyone knows that there is no stop to it. The top athletes will always get offered benefits from boosters and some will accept some won’t. A possible solution the NCAA could come up with to help reduce the problem is by paying athletes. They could pay them based off of the state that they live in. For example, an athlete in California would get paid more than an athlete in Nevada, but it would balance out because the cost of living in California is more expensive.
They don’t have to pay the athletes a ridiculous amount of money, but the NCAA could come up with a fair compensation system for the athletes. It wouldn’t hurt anyone to give the athletes a little spending money each month so that if they need something they can buy it themselves and not have to resort to boosters. This won’t eliminate boosters, but it would reduce athletes accepting gifts from them. Having a steady income will help athletes make smarter decisions and shy away from getting in contact with the boosters.
The NCAA has to figure a solution out. It is not fair to punish players who had nothing to do with scandals that happen with their programs. Things will only get worse, suspending players and placing sanctions on schools athletic programs isn’t enough to resolve the problem.